Governments failing to honour 1854 treaty

Tue. Dec. 20/11
Governments failing to honour 1854 treaty: chief; Snuneymuxw leader seeks meetings to gain access to Crown land parcels
2011-12-20T00:00:00
The Victoria Times Colonist
Judith Lavoie

Just before Christmas in 1854, the Snuneymuxw First Nation and James Douglas,  governor of the Colony of Vancouver Island, signed a treaty.

It was a respectful, government-to-government agreement that promised to  protect the Snuneymuxw way of life, said Chief Douglas White, who heads the  1,700-member Nanaimo band today.

So, why, on the 157th anniversary of that signing, is the band still fighting  for the basic rights promised in the treaty, asked White, who is hoping to ramp  up meetings with the federal and provincial governments to gain access to some  of the few remaining parcels of Crown land in the area.

"We need to address the injustice that my people have found themselves in  that has created grinding poverty," he said in an interview. "People here simply  have no room to live."

All growth is off-reserve because areas promised to Snuneymuxw in the treaty,  including traditional winter villages — which became Departure Bay and downtown  Nanaimo — are in private hands, White said.

The band has about 200 hectares of reserve land. The main reserve comprises  about 16 hectares surrounded by urban development.

Traditional livelihoods such as hunting, fishing and shellfish harvesting,  promised in the treaty, are impossible in many areas and Snuneymuxw has been  left out of modern economic development, said White, a lawyer.

He blames many of the problems on government's reluctance to admit that the  Douglas Treaties are binding, despite numerous wins by First Nations in the  courts.

Between 1850 and 1854, Douglas, who was also chief factor of Fort Victoria,  made a series of 14 land purchases from aboriginal peoples. The Douglas Treaties  cover about 930 square kilometres of land around Victoria, Saanich, Sooke,  Nanaimo and Port Hardy.

"Everyone in the world is making money right under our noses and we are not  getting one penny of that economic activity," said White, who is hoping meetings  with the federal and provincial governments will re-educate people about the  promises in the treaties.

"The people in every part of Canada need to sit down and look hard at their  relationship with aboriginal people," said Douglas, who would not rule out more  court cases.

The treaties promised to protect "village sites and enclosed fields," and to  allow hunting and fishing on First Nations territories.

However, within a short time, many treaty conditions had been abrogated,  exacerbated by the massive E&N land grant that put most of east Vancouver  Island in private hands.

Since then, First Nations and governments have been fighting about the  validity of some treaty provisions.

Aboriginal Affairs Canada spokesman Karl Freeborn said Canada recognizes the  Douglas Treaties as being protected under the constitution.

"There is, however, some uncertainty regarding the scope, application and  meaning of Douglas Treaty rights," he said.

"Consequently, any assertions of Douglas Treaty rights are reviewed on a  case-by-case basis."

The province respects and recognizes the historic treaties and consults with  Douglas Treaty nations on any decision that might affect treaty rights on  traditional territory, Aboriginal Relations spokeswoman Maria Wilkie said.

"We are especially aware of the requirement for consultation on any decisions  on the land that affects their hunting and fishing rights," she said.

The province is also talking to Snuneymuxw about incremental treaty  agreements and has provided $3 million for economic and business development,  she said.

A conference on pre-confederation treaties will be held at Vancouver Island  University in Nanaimo next May.